Disney Recipe: Try The Grey Stuff With This Recipe From Disney World and Disneyland!

By Rachel Franko 4 Comments

We’ve been baking up a storm recently with all those amazing Disney recipes (we’ve had Mickey Waffles like three times this week already).

Be Our Guest Sign

And, while you’re singing and dancing around your kitchen as you cook, you’re going to want to pull out your best silverware and plates for this next delicious treat!

We’re inviting you to be our guest and make the famous Grey Stuff from Red Rose Taverne in Disneyland and Be Our Guest Restaurant in Disney World! Although we might not have enchanted kitchenware like in Beauty and the Beast, this dessert is still just as fun to make at home.

We already shared a similar recipe when we were pairing some delicious Disney treats with Disney films, but there’s no need to start and stop a video with these step-by-step instructions below!

Ingredients

1 1/2 cups cold whole milk
1 (3.4 ounce) package instant vanilla pudding mix
15 chocolate sandwich cookies
1 (8 ounce) container whipped topping, thawed
3 tablespoons instant chocolate pudding mix
12 scalloped sugar cookies
Edible sugar pearls

Grey Stuff Gateau

Recipe

Pour milk into large mixing bowl. Add instant vanilla pudding mix and whisk for 2 minutes until smooth and slightly thickened. Place in the refrigerator for 1-2 hours, until firm.
Place chocolate sandwich cookies in food processor and pulse until puréed.
Fold puréed cookies into pudding mix. Stir until fully mixed.
Add whipped topping and instant chocolate pudding. Stir until fully mixed.
Place in refrigerator and chill for one hour.
Spoon grey stuff into piping bag fitted with desired tip. Pipe grey stuff onto cookies. Top with sugar pearls.

You can watch the full baking tutorial on how to make the Grey Stuff here! Bon appétit!

Who else here is grabbing ingredients from the cabinets as we speak??

Learn how to create more iconic treats from Disney films here!

Join the DFB Newsletterto get all the breaking news right in your inbox!Click here to Subscribe!

Have you ever tried the Grey Stuff in the Disney Parks? Let us know in the comments below!

« 4 Ways to Host the Ultimate Disney Backyard Barbecue

News! Häagen-Dazs Ice Cream in Disney Springs Will Start a Phased Reopening On May 20th »

TRENDING NOW

NEWS: Lights Are OFF on Spaceship Earth Tonight in EPCOT, and We Think We Know Why A Disney World ride had been closed for more than 3 hours on a busy... read more Celebrity Spotted in Disney World! You Won’t Believe Who Just Rode TRON and Had a Blast! Another celebrity recently went to Disney World and had the BEST time with her family! read more Disney’s Latest Tiana’s Bayou Adventure Announcement Is Going VIRAL and We Think We Know Why Tiana's Bayou Adventure is opening SOON in Disney World and we think we may know... read more I Go to Disney World Everyday. Here’s Where I Take a NAP When I Need One. We try to keep you as prepared as possible for your Disney World trips with... read more Sad Mimosa News: This is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things at Disney World Hotels Yet another one of our favorite things in Disney World is gone, and this time... read more 5 Rules You Need To Know Before You Fly with Southwest Airlines If you're flying with Southwest Airlines for the first time, or the first time in... read more 5 Unfortunate Things That Happen Every Time We Ride Space Mountain in Disney World Listen, we ALL experience these unfortunate things when riding Space Mountain... someone just had to... read more 6 Disney Myths that Cast Members Wish Would Just Go Away We are talking about the six myths that cast members wish would just go away! read more 7 Upcoming Dates to Avoid EPCOT Watch out for these six dates when visiting EPCOT at Disney World! read more A Disney+ Celebration Is Happening NOW in Disney Springs! Celebrate Hulu on Disney+ at Disney Springs and Downtown Disney! read more ALERT! You Need to Know About This Magic Kingdoms Fireworks Change Happily Ever After is going to CHANGE in Magic Kingdom tomorrow! read more Disney Announced a HUGE NEW PERK for Hotel Guests There's a HUGE new hotel perk coming to Disney World in 2025! read more Disney Sweatshirts Are ON SALE Up to 42% Off Online at Target Right Now! There's a major sale on Disney merchandise happening online right now! read more NEWS: Famous Imagineer Joe Rohde Is Temporarily BACK at Disney! Joe Rohde has temporarily returned to Walt Disney Imagineering -- get the details here! read more The 10 BEST Quick Service Restaurants in Magic Kingdom for 2024 What are the BEST Magic Kingdom Quick Service restaurants in 2024? We have the list... read more #OnTheList: Zebra Domes at Disney’s Animal Kingdom Lodge Zebra Domes from Disney's Animal Kingdom Lodge are the next in our series of Disney... read more 5 NEW Disney Loungefly Bags You Can Buy on Amazon Right Now Shop the NEW Disney Loungefly bags on Amazon NOW! read more 6 Completely Unnecessary Things People STILL Pay for in Disney World PLEASE. I'm BEGGING you. STOP paying for these totally, completely, unquestionably UNNECESSARY things at Disney... read more 6 Disney Loungefly Bags You’ll LOVE if Your Favorite Ride Is Jungle Cruise If you love dad jokes, adventure, and the back side of water, these are the... read more BREAKING: 3 NEW RIDES Announced for Universal’s Epic Universe The time has come for Universal to dive deeper into the rides at the new... read more

Comments

Marc Brown says
May 16, 2020 at 2:52 pm
This can NOT be the real recipe- I imagine the real grey stuff has actual homemade custard or creme pat blended with actual whipped cream. However, this does look like a great approximation to do with my daughter 💕
Dianna says
June 29, 2020 at 1:55 am
Why do you never include print buttons or pinterest buttons???
Roe says
January 2, 2021 at 3:06 pm
I loved the grey stuff at Beasts Castle and made this recipe at home with my deep chocolate moist recipe and it was delicious.
I don’t believe it is an exact Disney kitchen recipe but very close. My recipe makes a lot of cupcakes, so I handed them out to two neighbors, their response, wonderful and delicious.
Kate says
May 1, 2022 at 8:37 pm
I really enjoy trying your recipes, but I agree with Dianna’s comment. It would be much easier if you had a “printable” version of each recipe. As it is, I have to either print the entire page (can run to 16 sheets!), or take multiple screen shots & compile them into a usable recipe. Thanks.

Disney Recipe: Try The Grey Stuff With This Recipe From Disney World and Disneyland! | the disney food blog (2024)